We regret to announce that Road Test Reports will be closing down on 2nd October 2017


Mini One consumer car reviews and road tests

4.5 stars - average customer rating
Read all 10 reviews
Read road tests
Have your say!
How does it compare?
Recent responses | Recent questions | Recent answers
Lastest deals

What Do You Say...?

Mini One consumer reviews by year of make: 1969  2002  2003  2005  2006  2007  2008 

Mini One consumer car reviews

Sam Cook, Cheshire

Mini One 2006

5 star review

Great car. Joy to drive everyday. Buy the Mini one up to about 06 and you get a Cooper but better. Why better, well cheaper to run and it has smother and more economical engine mapping. Easy to change to Cooper power when needed on track days etc. The report that you have to rev the engine is far from true, it drives brill between 2 and 3 thousand revs. Test drive one, I find one improvement could be made in sound insulation on motorway.<br /><br />

Submitted: 2012-08-06 | ID: 43430

Bill Braithwaite, Spain

Mini One 1.4 2008

5 star review

I live in Tenerife, Canary Islands, and have found my Mini to be an excellent choice. There are only two of us and so space is not a problem. The car is a joy to drive, well made, solid on the road, and economical. No hesitation in awarding 5 stars.

Submitted: 2012-04-03 | ID: 43431

Dave Bosworth, Warwickshire

Mini One 2002

5 star review

Fantastic car, reliable, great to drive. No problems ever. I’ve swapped it now for a little larger car for the kids. Looking forward to the kids leaving home, counting the days down. Mini days will be back.

Submitted: 2011-05-10 | ID: 43428

Michael Bignell, New Zealand

Mini One Hatch 2003

4 star review

Great car in almost every department-steering, handling, body control, equipment, shape, usability and more. Disappointments: Could use a few more inches in length, some annoying rattles letting down the general build quality but worst of all the cvt transmission is controlled by a horrible clunky lever and when cold or manoevering it’s quite embarrassingly jerky. Ignoring that it’s fun to drive, economical and not thirsty. I would love to add a reversing camera and head up speed and gear display.<br /><br />

Submitted: 2010-07-21 | ID: 43429

Mike, England

Mini One One diesel 2005

3 star review

Firstly, under the county heading why is there no Merseyside or do you think we can not afford BMW’s up here? Right, here goes with the review. We have owned the uprated diesel varient from new, Oct 2005, and will start with the type of MPG you can expect around town 50+ mpg is the average my wife gets with any effort when driven more frugally 55 can be achieved and on a run well over 60 is easilly capable. Good bits: Great to drive, feels solid with excellent handling light and airy inside with the large sunshine roof, extra cost option and most important the wife absolutely loves it still, even after four years. The bad bits: According to my wife, there aren’t that many...I disagree...Build quality is poor some parts of the interior look solid and well built others look and feels shamefully cheap and nasty. have had THREE rear washers replaced.....BMW say no problem it is the washer fluid I use gumming up and there is not an issue, I disagree as I don’t use washer solution only plain water I think it a bad design which rusts and blocks the jet. The sunroof, dashboard and just about anything not nailed down rattles while driving. Paint quality is poor and stone chips appear too easily and touch up paint is never the correct shade. The wipers sound like chalk on a blackboard, I suspect due to the upright design of the windscreen. The BMW dealer experience was poor compared to my experience with Mercedes and Ford and on the last visit to thelocal dealer they damaged the car and took them almost 2 months to rectify with barely an apology. BMW no better when filling the customer satifaction survey a question was asked if I would like some contact from BMW re problems at last visit, well 5 months on and I’m still waiting for them to contact me. All that said My wife still adores the car, I still love driving the thing. Would I buy another? Probably not.......but then never say never. The good bits probably out weigh the bad bits..but only just.

Submitted: 2009-12-05 | ID: 43427

Tony Ward, Yorkshire

Mini One 1969

5 star review

If it’s called Mini one and is a car made by Germans - is it a Mini or a BMW? The only Minis in the world that deserve the name Mini are the classic Minis; the rest are BMW’s. Real Mini drivers don’t acknowledge BMW as a Mini, so if you have problems with your BMW call a German dealer.

Responses to this review

Minis are made in the UK not Germany, probably by Poles. Remember if you have an original Mini, don’t call a German dealer as they will only laugh at you. Phone a British Leyland dealer instead - Andy Parsons from Durham

Submitted: 2009-02-11 | ID: 43436

Dave, Lancashire

Mini One 2005

5 star review

Top notch little motor. Got one for my wife but I love driving it. I am 6 feet 4, but fit into it without a problem. Sticks to the road like glue and performance is great . Needs revving hard to get the best out of it. Superb fun and has held its value quite well.

Submitted: 2008-11-12 | ID: 43435

Steve Farndon, England

Mini One 2008

4 star review

Hi - anyone know how to turn off the Ambient lighting please - reply to hilsalter@yahoo.co.uk Thanks

Submitted: 2008-08-04 | ID: 43434

Mike Randall, Devon

Mini One 1.6 One 2007

4 star review

The drive is brilliant, handles nicely and copes with rough road surfaces. Quiet purring engine. A joy to drive, it may be small but it is perfectly made. Only downside is that part are not cheap.

Submitted: 2007-10-31 | ID: 43432

Lorna Connell, Nottinghamshire

Mini One 2007

4 star review

Great run around, roomy inside, park in the smallest of space. Great responsive handling. However parts are expensive to replace.

Submitted: 2007-08-28 | ID: 43433

What Do You Say...?


  • A response has been made to Tony Ward (11/02/2009 09:05:16)


  • "I have had my Mini for 5 weeks and have noticed a creaking noise coming from driver’s back-end when going over bumps. The garage does not seem to kno..." (Maria del Busso, 30/09/2010 10:00:03)
    Can you help? Read the question in full and provide an answer
  • "Can you please recommend any decent Mini specialists in the North West of England? I am looking to get my ’98 Mini restored to factory new condition...." (J Q, 17/09/2010 09:33:35)
    Can you help? Read the question in full and provide an answer


  • Maria del Busso's question has been answered: "Most likely to be the rubber bushes. - Doove Dave from England' '..." (06/01/2014 10:19:33)
    Read the full question and answer

Road tests

Mini One

Clubman - Mini has chosen a good time to launch the latest member of its model range, the One Clubman. The new entry-level estate enters the market just as the iconic little city car celebrates its 50th birthday, but it’s also a good time to launch a car that returns 52.3mpg and emits just 130g/km as we all w [...]

Road Test Reports Says 3.5 star ratingFull Report
An image of the Mini One Clubman

^ Back to Top

How does it compare?

Ford Fiesta

3.5 stars - average customer rating
Average driver rating ( based on 183 reviews )

Toyota Yaris

3 stars - average customer rating
Average driver rating ( based on 177 reviews )

Vauxhall Corsa

3 stars - average customer rating
Average driver rating ( based on 145 reviews )

Toyota Aygo

3 stars - average customer rating
Average driver rating ( based on 129 reviews )

Peugeot 207

2.5 stars - average customer rating
Average driver rating ( based on 104 reviews )

Honda Jazz

3.5 stars - average customer rating
Average driver rating ( based on 92 reviews )

Vauxhall Meriva

3 stars - average customer rating
Average driver rating ( based on 86 reviews )

Ford Ka

3.5 stars - average customer rating
Average driver rating ( based on 73 reviews )

Citroen C2

3 stars - average customer rating
Average driver rating ( based on 66 reviews )

Fiat Grande Punto

3.5 stars - average customer rating
Average driver rating ( based on 64 reviews )